The European Council and Parliament reached a provisional agreement on regulating ESG rating providers. The objective is to enhance investor confidence in sustainable products by improving transparency and reliability in ESG ratings.
Understanding ESG Ratings
In a nutshell, ESG ratings assess the sustainability profile of a company or financial instrument, considering its exposure to sustainability risks and its impact on society and the environment.
Key Regulatory Measures
This new regulation will require EU-based ESG rating providers to be authorised and supervised by the ESMA (the European markets regulator) and to adhere to measures promoting transparency and reducing conflicts of interests.
Clarity on Regulation Scope
The proposal clarifies the circumstances and territorial scope of the regulation, defining when ESG ratings fall within its scope and what constitutes operating in the EU.
It is worth noting that the proposal includes alternate or lighter requirements for:
- non-EU ratings providers to operate in the EU (such as obtaining endorsement by an EU-authorised ESG rating provider or being included in the EU registry of ESG rating providers subject to an equivalence decision) and
- small ESG ratings providers, which may opt for a temporary 3-year regime enabling them to benefit from supervisory fees proportional to the extent of ESMA's supervision.
Importance of Transparency
Transparency is central for financial market participants or advisers disclosing ESG ratings. Any marketing communications involving ESG ratings must include detailed information about methodologies on respective websites, offering stakeholders a comprehensive understanding.
Flexibility in Rating Factors
The proposal introduces the flexibility to provide separate or combined E (environmental), S (social), and G (governance) ratings. The weighting of these factors, if presented as a single rating, must be explicitly stated.
Next steps and Implementation Timeline
Formal adoption by the EU Council and Parliament is pending, with the rules expected to be implemented 18 months later.
Key contacts
Laurent Godts
Laurent is a key member of the Banking and Finance department at Deloitte Legal, where he has been instrumental in leading the practice since 2021. Promoted to Senior Director in 2024, he has consistently demonstrated exceptional expertise in the legal aspects of transactional finance, including syndicated finance, project finance, and structured finance. His practice also extends to high-end financial regulation assignments within the banking, insurance, and funds sectors. Laurent's experience is further enriched by a nine-month secondment in 2010 with a London-based international financial institution, providing him with invaluable insight into the global financial landscape. He advises clients on a comprehensive range of banking and finance-related matters, with a particular emphasis on the emerging Fintech sector. His work includes structuring peer-to-peer lending platforms and advising on Initial Coin Offerings (ICOs). Recognized as a "Rising Star" and consistently recommended as a "Next Generation Lawyer" since 2017 by Legal 500, Laurent has built a reputation for his pragmatic and commercial approach to legal challenges. The most recent Chambers feedback on his team reflects this excellence, describing Deloitte Legal's services as highly reactive, proactive, and precise.
Jolien Bradt
Jolien is a Senior Managing Associate in the Banking & Finance team at Deloitte Legal in Brussels. Before joining Deloitte Legal, Jolien was an investment banker for almost 3 years, which helped her to grasp the financial and commercial reasoning behind transactions. Before being an investment banker, Jolien worked as a banking & finance legal counsel (either in law firms or in-house) for 7 years. Jolien holds a LL.M in Banking & Finance law from Queen Mary, University of London, a master of laws from Ghent University and a postgraduate degree in corporate finance from the Catholic University Leuven.
